What Happens to a Military Pension After 20 or More Years of Service When a Marriage Ends

Military retirement pay earned over a long career is often among the most significant assets present in a military divorce. It pays monthly for life, may include annual cost-of-living adjustments, and can include survivor benefit provisions that extend its reach beyond the retiree’s own lifetime. When a long military marriage ends, questions about how that retirement benefit may be addressed under Virginia law are common and understandable.

The Federal Framework: The Uniformed Services Former Spouses’ Protection Act

The division of military retired pay in a divorce is generally governed at the federal level by the Uniformed Services Former Spouses’ Protection Act (USFSPA), a law enacted by Congress in 1982. The USFSPA authorized state courts to treat disposable military retired pay as property subject to division under state law, while leaving questions of how and how much to the applicable state property framework.

The USFSPA permits state courts to apply their own property division rules to this category of federal benefit. In Virginia, that means the equitable distribution framework of Virginia Code § 20-107.3 generally governs how a court may approach the pension, subject to the limitations and requirements imposed by federal law.

Disposable Retired Pay and Its Limitations

The USFSPA applies to what it defines as disposable retired pay, which differs from gross retired pay. Certain deductions — including amounts a servicemember may waive to receive VA disability compensation — can reduce the disposable figure. The U.S. Supreme Court addressed the intersection of VA disability compensation and military retirement division in Mansell v. Mansell (1989). That decision addressed the extent to which state courts may treat waived retirement pay as divisible property. The interaction between VA disability compensation and retirement division is an area of some legal complexity, and its application in any particular case depends on the specific facts and current governing law. Attorney review of this issue is appropriate before drawing any conclusions.

How Virginia Law Generally Approaches Military Retired Pay in Divorce

Virginia is an equitable distribution state. Under Virginia Code § 20-107.3, courts may divide marital property — which can include a portion of military retired pay — in a manner they determine to be equitable given the circumstances of the marriage. Equitable distribution does not mean equal division; courts consider a range of statutory factors, including the contributions of each spouse to the marriage, the duration of the marriage, the ages and circumstances of the parties, and other relevant factors the statute identifies. The outcome in any individual case depends on how those factors apply to the specific facts presented.

The Marital Share of a Military Pension

Under Virginia’s equitable distribution framework, generally only the portion of a military pension attributable to service during the marriage may be treated as marital property. The portion attributable to service before the marriage — or, where service continues after the divorce, the portion attributable to post-divorce service — may be treated as the servicemember’s separate property. The precise calculation depends on case-specific factors, including:

• The date the marriage began
• The date used to define the end of the marital period for calculation purposes
• The total years of creditable military service at retirement
• The years of creditable service that overlapped with the marriage

A fraction — sometimes called the marital coverture fraction — is often used to represent the marital share. Its application, and the specific dates and methodology used to calculate it, can vary depending on the facts, the court’s approach, and the terms of any settlement agreement. These are matters that an experienced military divorce attorney can help evaluate in context.

The marital share of a military pension depends on case-specific factors including when the marriage began, when the marital period ends for calculation purposes, and the total length of the servicemember’s career. These determinations can vary from case to case.

Percentage-Based vs. Fixed-Dollar Awards

When military retired pay is addressed in a Virginia divorce, a court order or settlement agreement may express the former spouse’s share either as a percentage of the disposable retired pay or as a fixed dollar amount. These two structures can produce different financial outcomes over time, particularly in cases where the retirement benefit includes cost-of-living adjustments. The financial impact of these approaches may differ depending on the facts of the case, the length of time benefits are paid, and other circumstances. An attorney can help explain how these structures may apply to a particular situation.

Timing of the Calculation

Another question that may arise in military pension division is whether the former spouse’s share is calculated based on the servicemember’s pay grade and service credit at the time of divorce, or at the time of retirement. Different approaches can produce different outcomes depending on the facts, including whether the servicemember’s rank or longevity changes between the divorce and the date of retirement. The application of these approaches in Virginia can depend on the terms negotiated by the parties, the language of the court order, and potentially changes in federal law affecting military pension division calculations. This is an area where attorney review of current law and the specific circumstances is appropriate.

The Military Retired Pay Division Order

Division of military retired pay in a divorce requires a court order that satisfies the requirements of the Defense Finance and Accounting Service (DFAS) before direct payments can be processed. This order is commonly referred to as a Military Retired Pay Division Order, or MRPDO. DFAS has published requirements governing the content and format of qualifying orders. Orders that do not meet those requirements may not be processed by DFAS. The specific requirements, and what constitutes a compliant order, are matters that an attorney experienced in military divorce document preparation can address.

The 10/10 Rule and DFAS Direct Payment

The USFSPA includes a provision commonly referred to as the 10/10 rule, which governs whether DFAS will make payments directly to a former spouse from the servicemember’s retired pay account. Generally, for DFAS to process direct payments to a former spouse, the parties must have been married for at least 10 years, with those years overlapping at least 10 years of creditable military service. This threshold addresses the direct payment mechanism only. Virginia courts may still address a share of retired pay in a divorce proceeding regardless of whether the 10/10 threshold is met; the question of how that share would then be paid is a separate matter. The application of the 10/10 rule to any specific case depends on the facts and current law, and an attorney can help evaluate how it may apply.

The Survivor Benefit Plan

The Survivor Benefit Plan (SBP) is a federal program that can provide a continuing monthly benefit to a surviving former spouse after a military retiree’s death. Whether and how SBP coverage for a former spouse may be addressed as part of a Virginia military divorce depends on several factors, including the terms negotiated by the parties and the language of the court order. SBP provisions can have long-term financial implications depending on the structure of the agreement and the circumstances of the parties. Because the rules governing SBP elections, coverage levels, and premiums involve both federal law and case-specific facts, these provisions are best addressed with the assistance of counsel.

SBP Election Timing

Federal law generally establishes timeframes within which SBP elections and related filings may be made following a divorce. Procedures exist for situations where a required election is not timely made, including what is sometimes referred to as a deemed election process. The specific requirements, deadlines, and procedures governing SBP elections and any related DFAS filings are subject to federal law and agency requirements that can change. An attorney can help identify what steps may be available in a particular situation.

Federal Civilian Benefits: FERS, CSRS, and the Thrift Savings Plan

In some military divorce cases, particularly those involving servicemembers who have also had federal civilian careers, additional retirement benefits may be present. Benefits under the Federal Employees Retirement System (FERS) or the Civil Service Retirement System (CSRS) are governed by federal law distinct from the USFSPA and generally require a separately prepared Court Order Acceptable for Processing (COAP) submitted to the Office of Personnel Management. A Thrift Savings Plan (TSP) account may require a separate Retirement Benefits Court Order (RBCO). The identification of all applicable benefit streams in a given case, and the preparation of the appropriate order for each, is an area where experienced military and federal employment divorce counsel can help.

Contact the Law Offices of Michael Kevin Murphy, PLLC

The attorneys at the Law Offices of Michael Kevin Murphy, PLLC have served Northern Virginia military families since 1982. Attorney Michael Kevin Murphy is a VMI graduate and former U.S. Army officer. The firm’s experience with military and federal benefit division matters across Northern Virginia — in Fairfax, Arlington, Alexandria, Loudoun, Prince William, and Stafford Counties — informs the practical understanding it brings to these cases.

To schedule a consultation, call 703-385-9330 Monday through Friday, 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. Video consultations are available.

educational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice. Reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship. The application of law described in this article depends on the specific facts of each case and the current state of applicable law. Please consult a qualified attorney regarding your individual circumstances.

Sonnet 4.6